Monthly Archives: December 2011

Ginie Reviews Books: The Iron King

Title: The Iron King
Author:
 Julie Kagawa
Genre:
 YA/Fantasy
Rating:
3.5/5

I wanted to like this book. And to be fair, there were a great many things I did enjoy about this book. I thought there were some aspects that were quite wonderfully creepy (which is what I always look for in any story involving the fey) and I liked the incorporation of faery mythology that was familiar, i.e. Puck, Oberon, Titania, the Seelie and Unseelie courts as well as faery mythology entirely of Kagawa’s own making i.e. the Iron Fey. I also thought that the concept behind the Iron Fey was really great and quite clever in how it takes into account how dreams and ideals change with time.

However. Oh god however. There were so many things that kept niggling at me throughout the entire book.

First of all – I hate how science and technology is completely demonised. I understand the fey are allergic to iron, and I think it’s a clever way of working in traditional mythology but the way that science is always consistently described as lacking in imagination makes me want to throw the book against the wall. I’m not a scientist, but you know what? Someone had to dream that a man could one day walk on the moon. Someone had to dream that we’d one day be able to transplant one human heart to another in order to save a life. Science requires at least as much imagination as the arts do, and sure – not all of the ‘progress’ we’ve made has been good. In fact a lot of it has done a considerable amount of damage to our environment. But you know what else? It’s the same science and technology that’s trying to find ways to save the planet. To improve our processes so that we don’t hurt the environment any more. So stop giving me this bullshit that science and technology and progress is all just one heap of unimaginative evil. Argh!

My other concerns are somewhat more typical of YA. I love Puck, but then I have a weakness for tricksters. Ash feels like a pale imitation of Rath Roiben Rye from Holly Black’s Modern Faerie Tales series and it annoys me that just about every single YA book with a female lead MUST contain a love triangle as it’s central plot point.

Also, what’s up with the whole “princess” thing? I mean, I get that she’s a princess but all I could think of everytime Puck called her that was:

I’d be willing to forgive the romantic triangle if Meghan (the main character) was a stronger character. She started off quite promising, but I can’t help but feel incredibly frustrated with her terrible decision-making and her general helplessness. Obviously I’m not asking her to be some kind of amazing action hero – I get it. She’s a human in a world where every single being is more powerful than she is (at least as far as she’s aware), but some of the terrible decisions she makes seem to be contrived for the sole excuse of having her saved by one of her two suitors and it is very frustrating.

As for the villain, I felt very let down when we finally got to him. Machina was nowhere near as scary as her younger brother Ethan’s “man in the closet” and his motivations for kidnapping Meghan’s brother seemed very flimsy. Also, he was defeated far too easily. I think it would have been more interesting to have the Iron King be someone Meghan knew, someone like the man she thought was her father. While that may have been predictable, at least it would have provided for more of an emotional conflict beyond “I love Ash, but I can’t have him!”

So yes. I had many issues with this book. But – all of that said I still read it all in one sitting and I’m still planning to read the sequels. Because it is fun. If YA fiction involving faeries is your cup of tea then I would recommend it but just be aware of the above issues. YMMV.

Ginie

Leave a comment

Filed under Books, Review